man has been told he must serve at least 25 years in prison for murdering his niece, by a judge who refused to speculate on whether the killing was in response to “some appalling family agreement”.
Repair man Mohammed Taroos Khan, 53, killed Somaiya Begum, 20, in an attack at her home in Binnie Street, Bradford, West Yorkshire, on June 25 last year, before dumping her body on waste ground where it was found decomposed 11 days later.
Miss Begum had been living at the property with another of her uncles and her grandmother under the terms of a forced marriage protection order, following attempts by her father, Mohammed Yaseen Khan, to force her to marry a cousin from Pakistan “by threat of violence”, a jury heard.
I decline to speculate on your motive and I reject the prosecution’s suggestion that I should treat this as any form of so-called honour killing
Sentencing Khan to life in prison at Bradford Crown Court on Wednesday, Mr Justice Garnham said: “It is not possible to identify a motive for this dreadful attack by you on an innocent young woman.
“It is said you did not support her forced marriage to the cousin in Pakistan.
“It is said you did not share the view of your brother, Yaseen, about the role of women or the obligation of Somaiya to obey her father.
“Moreover, it is pure speculation to consider whether this murder was portion of some appalling family agreement.
“All that matters for present purposes is that the jury gain found you guilty of the heinous crime of murder.
“I decline to speculate on your motive and I reject the prosecution’s suggestion that I should treat this as any form of so-called honour killing.”
Khan was found guilty of murder on Tuesday.
The grey-haired defendant sat in the glass-fronted dock wearing a grey fleece and a black body-warmer and flanked by two security officers as the judge outlined the callousness with which he disposed of his niece’s body.
You showed absolutely no respect for the dead body of your niece in the way you dumped it unceremoniously, wrapped in carpet and covered in scrap material, amongst rubbish on waste ground
Mr Justice Garnham told him: “You showed absolutely no respect for the dead body of your niece in the way you dumped it unceremoniously, wrapped in carpet and covered in scrap material, amongst rubbish on waste ground.
“You left it there to rot in the summer heat and, when it was found, Somaiya’s face had been eaten away by maggots.
“Inevitably the loss of this shimmering, vibrant young woman is felt acutely by other members of her family.”
The judge described Miss Begum as “an intelligent young woman of real spirit and courage” and recalled that her uncle, Dawood Khan, had referred to her in court as the “light of his life”.
The jury heard that Miss Begum’s family had already been split in two by a previous dispute before her father’s attempts to force her to marry when she was 16.
The trial was told that her body was so decomposed it was not possible to determine her cause of death but she had a metal spike embedded in her back.
Khan admitted perverting the course of justice, by disposing of the body and attempting to burn Miss Begum’s phone.
He declined to give evidence in his defence during the trial but his barrister told the court that his brother – Miss Begum’s father, Yaseen Khan – had a clearer motive for murder and had subsequently fled to Pakistan using a one-way ticket.
The court heard that Miss Begum had lived under strict conditions as a teenager with her mother and father but, after she went to the police over the forced marriage threat and secured the protection order, she was delighted living in Binnie Street.
She had been studying at Leeds Beckett University and supporting herself with a job as a carer, also in Leeds.
Khan subjected Somaiya to a horrendous attack for reasons only known to him
Detective Superintendent Marc Bowes, from West Yorkshire Police, said Miss Begum was killed in a “vicious and sustained attack”.
He said Khan’s disposal of his niece’s body was “despicable” and “can only be described as beyond belief”.
Mr Bowes said: “Somaiya was a shimmering young woman who was studying to acquire a degree, had a portion-time job to support herself and was delighted and content with home life.
“She had her whole life ahead of her and it was cruelly slice short by her uncle, someone who is meant to admire, care and protect her.
“Khan subjected Somaiya to a horrendous attack for reasons only known to him.
“Khan went to extreme lengths to cover up his crime; he dumped her body in wasteland, showing complete disregard and disrespect for human life, with the hope that her body would never be found.”
Asked why he thought Khan had killed Miss Begum, the officer said: “I don’t consider we will ever know. The only person that knows that is Khan himself.”
Mr Bowes said he understands that a domestic homicide review is due to seize space into the background to the murder.
Senior Crown Prosecutor Daniel Lee said: “Somaiya Begum was a young woman who had her whole life ahead her.
“Her murder is a tragedy and Khan now faces the consequences for his appalling crimes.”
Mr Lee said: “Women gain the factual to be safe and feel safe. The Crown Prosecution Service is committed to securing justice and will always seek to hold violent offenders to account for their crime.”